No Apologies Necessary

Children’s music workshop at the Collateral Repair Project Refugee Community Center

“I am Rania!”

A friend and I are sitting near the steps to Amman’s ancient Roman citadel when a bright-faced little
girl – no more than three feet tall – appears beside us. Tugging at my friend’s pant leg, the girl offers
a loud “Hello! How are you! I am Rania!” The words spill quickly from her mouth as her lips
blossom into a proud smile. She is obviously pleased about having addressed us in English and
begins twirling in circles playfully. “Where are you from, Rania?” My Arabic surprises her, and she
stops mid-twirl. “Syria,” she says, and continues to spin.

Rania, age eight, spends evenings at her family’s roadside snack stand with her barely-older sister just
outside the citadel’s entrance. I ask her about herself, and she happily tells me that her favorite color
is red, that she dislikes math and that her family is from Damascus, all while continuing to twirl in
circles. “And now seven of us live in one room,” she added abruptly yet unconcernedly.

My response, which I immediately regret, is an apologetic one. “Why are you sorry?” she asks,
confused by my change in mood. I say nothing, and so Rania continues to twirl and sway, this time
adding a song, the lyrics of which I cannot understand. I tell her that I too am a singer, and so she
patiently teaches me the words. Her song distracts me from my thoughts – about Syria, about other
children like Rania, and about the six other people with whom she shares a one-room home.

Rania is one of more than 140,000 Syrian children in Jordan, a demographic that comprises one-fifth of the total number of displaced Syrians in the Hashemite Kingdom. While most are urban refugees
that live in and around Jordanian cities, 165,000 Syrians have been accommodated in the country’s
refugee camps.

No stranger to refugees like Rania and her family, Jordan maintains a longstanding tradition of
hospitality toward displaced persons that began with the 1948 Arab-Israeli war and the nearly 2
million Palestinians that followed. More recently, masses of Iraqis entered Jordan after the 2003 US
Invasion of Iraq and today almost half of one million remain. Add to these dizzying numbers the
thousands of Sudanese and Somali families in-country and you are left with the highest
concentration of displaced persons relative to a country’s size found anywhere in the world.

A music workshop for Syrian children during a home visit in Amman

“Anta Amrikii?”

I have come to Jordan to learn more about these communities, and to explore opportunities for how
musical engagement can be used to promote youth development in displaced children. In what is
primarily an outreach project, I am working in collaboration with local musicians and aid
organizations to establish or strengthen music-based programming for young refugees.

My project is led by two basic assumptions; namely, that music is a tool apt for promoting wellbeing
in youth, and likewise, that there exists a specific need within refugee communities for means and
modes of healing. While these are concepts that I believe in, they are also ones embedded with
presuppositions regarding the needs of displaced persons and the means appropriate for addressing
those needs.

In the broadest of terms, my project raises questions about the delicate nature of “helping” across
boarders. International humanitarian programming and its associated aid economies represent a
complex world in which good intentions are easily lost in translation. As such, work of this kind demands that international actors examine how the process of entering another’s community and
culture can harm those they intend to help.

In my own work, I strive to understand how the cross-cultural community music practice interacts
with issues of cultural access, transaction and intrusion. In most societies, music is a practice for
defining and contesting cultural meanings, traditions and identities. This is especially true of
traditional children’s music, which can be used as a mode of socialization to promote specific values
and principles (“…one is silver and the other gold”; “…sweet land of liberty, for thee I sing”;
“…where seldom is heard a discouraging word”).

Thus, it remains a central priority in my programming efforts to find the necessary cultural
boundaries between ‘visiting and ‘trespassing’.

On Storytelling & Dignity

“The consequence of the single story is this: It robs people of dignity. It makes our recognition of our equal humanity difficult. It emphasizes how we are different rather than how we are similar.” – Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

A dominant narrative in media and international discourse about refugees in Jordan and its
neighboring countries is one of suffering. A Google news search of the keywords “Syria” “Jordan”
“Refugee” and “Children” returns several articles that refer to Syrian youth as a “lost generation”
rendered incapacitated by their trauma. Similar material was also published about Iraqi refugee youth
in the years following 2003.

My own experiences in Jordan challenge the narrative that narrowly confines displaced people to
their pain and suffering. This is not to say that media outlets exaggerate the abuses and difficulties
faced by many refugees, but rather that those negotiating such realities often do so with a sense of
dignity and resilience unacknowledged in depictions of total and utter desperation.

Throughout January, I helped to organize a series of songwriting workshops for Syrian and Iraqi
youth in collaboration with the Jordanian community music initiative Bmajor. The workshops used
an exercise that guides participants in writing the lyrics and harmony of a song without creative
input from session leaders.

Our first workshop was for a group of Syrian children and teenagers at Syria Bright Future, a refugee
community center in Amman. After hearing a short piece of live music, participants were asked to
reflect on their listening experiences and then find a common theme for the song’s title. Agreeing on
‘Aamal’, or hope, they went on to write the following piece:

My homeland is the sun of Freedom/ Love is the light of the sky/
The Children are the birds of the future/ Music is the voice of the stars/
Syria is earth’s HeavenHave patience for the hope of return!

A week later, we gave a similar workshop to a group of Iraqi teenagers at the Collateral Repair
Project (CRP) community center. Without input from workshop leaders, the group also chose to
title their piece ‘Hope’:

In this world, we see everything/ Maybe happiness, maybe sorrow or fear/
The journey of happiness starts with a smile/ in failure there is hope for success./
Music is the spirit of life.

Named the “Dream Group”, the teens in the video above gather each week at CRP to discuss topics
and issues that they find important or interesting. The group – which is predominately Iraqi, though
also includes Syrian and Jordanian teens – is several years old, and many of its members have been
coming to the center since they were little. Included among them is an accomplished visual artist,
two talented guitarists and a gifted writer. Several of them also volunteer regularly to help with
clothing and food voucher distributions at the center.

These wonderful young people have come of age in protracted displacement. Unable to work legally
or to obtain citizenship in Jordan, some of the teens at CRP come from families that are dependent
on the support of aid organizations for basic resources. Undoubtedly, their stories involve loss – loss
of home, of country and, often, of loved ones.

Yet it is a disservice to think of their stories as a one-dimensional narrative about loss, or to
represent them as a “lost generation”, for these young people are so much more than the sum of
their hardship.

Wednesday, February 19th, 2014 Video

19 Comments to No Apologies Necessary

  1. garrett,
    you are a most amazing talented young man.
    sing on, sing on for peace, sing on for a better
    world for the children<3 <3 <3
    love you very much
    sara

  2. sara on February 19th, 2014
  3. Garrett,
    I commend you for the gift you are bringing to children from challenged worlds. You are a brave and loving man. Here’s to you and your work.

  4. Kristie Shaw on February 19th, 2014
  5. “these young people are so much more than the sum of
    their hardship.”

    The only thing better than the work you’re doing and the experiences you’re having, is your ability to describe them so well.

  6. Leland on February 19th, 2014
  7. Incredible work, my friend!!! Looking forward to learning from your future posts and partaking in similar work in displaced indigenous youth in Brazil.

  8. Rebeca on February 19th, 2014
  9. Garrett,
    Beautiful work and thought provoking, inspiring story telling. Sending you love and gratitude for doing such amazing work in the world.

    Caroline

  10. Caroline on February 20th, 2014
  11. Hi Garrett, it’s the beautiful soulwork being done by loving, compassionate people like you that brings me hope. I still remember your early on project about women and our trip to the elephant refuge. Wonderful, joyful, caring. Sending all the love I can gather for you! Hope to see you on one of your journeys “home”. Love, Jan

  12. Jan Nottingham on February 20th, 2014
  13. Garrett, beautiful message and even more beautiful experiences and images of the youth and their hope, mashallah. I am sincerely inspired and pray that you continue to inspire, uplift, and learn through your efforts and exploration of music as a tool for healing.

  14. Armaan on February 21st, 2014
  15. Garrett, your work with these young people is inspiring! I look forward to following your blogs. All the best, DBF

  16. Donna Brink Fox on February 22nd, 2014
  17. Garrett,

    Simply amazing. Keep up.the good work. I cannot wait to read more.

    Love,

    Your big brother

  18. Daniel on February 22nd, 2014
  19. Garrett,
    Brilliant how you have used your incredible talent to inspire these young children. You talent for storytelling gives us a sense of what you are experiencing. Thanks for sharing and I look forward to reading more. Take care. Love, your cousin Barbara

  20. Bee Eastman on February 22nd, 2014
  21. Garrett, I am one of your aunt Sara’s oldest friends and know your parents as well. She shared your blog with me and I am so touched by it. You are a gifted story teller and the world needs to hear the stories you are witnessing and telling. I am glad to see that while you are learning, doing good and spreading joy, you seem to be the recipient as well.
    I look forward to reading more tales of the Rubin in Jordan.
    Linda

  22. Linda Fidelman on March 2nd, 2014
  23. Hi Garrett, I’m so proud of you and the work you’re doing. I hope you’re well and finding joy in your work every day. I miss you!

    Love,
    Berri

  24. Berri Garver on March 8th, 2014
  25. Garrett,
    you are representing ESM’s ideals and varied missions to its fullest.
    I honor and admire you in yours!!

    Prof. O

  26. Jan Opalach on March 8th, 2014
  27. I have fun with, lead to I discovered exactly what I was having a
    look for. You’ve ended my 4 day long hunt!
    God Bless you man. Have a great day. Bye

  28. games for mobile phone on March 23rd, 2014
  29. Я думаю, что Вы не правы. Я уверен.
    Давайте обсудим это. Пишите мне в PM, поговорим.

  30. как бросить курить быстро on March 29th, 2014
  31. I read this article fully about the resemblance of hottest and earlier technologies, it’s remarkable article.

  32. watch neighbors on April 23rd, 2014
  33. Awesome site you have here but I was curious about if you knew of any message boards that
    cover the same topics talked about in this article? I’d really love to be a part
    of community where I can get feedback from other knowledgeable people that
    share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please
    let me know. Many thanks!

  34. my singing monsters cheats for android on May 5th, 2014
  35. whoah this blog is magnificent i like studying your articles.
    Keep up the good work! You understand, many individuals are searching around for this information, you could aid them greatly.

  36. 8 ball pool multiplayer hack.rar on May 13th, 2014
  37. Garrett Garrett Garrett – I am unable to express how this touched me. The story of your time with Rania brought such a vivid image of a little girl happily twirling with an innocence that all children deserve …the idea that the reality of her world and future could destroy her desire to “twirl” breaks my heart. The work you are doing brings so much hope to so many people although I know your first reaction is to say that they bring more to you than you to them but there is no need for such thinking. You need each other equally for so many reasons. You may be the youngest of the Rubin 5 gifts and 1 present but you are by far the most dedicated, intuitive and internally versed of us all. All my Love – your younger oldest sister.

  38. Heather Rubin on July 24th, 2014

Leave a comment

Archives

In partnership with Fulbright